Racial Profiling is Un-American?
Thursday, August 17th, 2006RealClearPolitics - Articles - Racial Profiling is Un-American
During an interview on “Fox News Sunday,” host Chris Wallace asked Homeland Security chief Michael Chertoff if we shouldn’t engage in “security profiling” of Muslims who want to get on airplanes instead of “wasting time” screening 85-year-old grandmothers — even if such profiling isn’t “politically correct.” (From the way the question was phrased, Wallace presumably was talking about 85-year-old grandmothers who aren’t Muslim.)Chertoff could have answered the question in a variety of ways. He could have talked about how it’s wrong to single out members of a particular ethnic group when — as Wallace acknowledged — “all Muslims aren’t terrorists.”
While I am against maligning a whole group of people because a small subset of them are bad, Mr. Navarrette has conveniently only put in half of the equation here. When he quotes Wallace as saying “all Muslims aren’t terrorists”, he neglects to point out that almost all terrorists are Muslim, from Abdel Rahman al-Rashed
“It is a certain fact that not all Muslims are terrorists, but it is equally certain, and exceptionally painful, that almost all terrorists are Muslims. … We cannot clear our names unless we own up to the shameful fact that terrorism has become an Islamic enterprise; an almost exclusive monopoly, implemented by Muslim men and women.”
This would strongly support profiling Muslims (whatever their ethnic background). Now, how you would go about identifying who is Muslim and who is not is another problem, as they can be anyone, just like the rest of the religions. That said, I am also against the government being able to pull aside anyone they want to and invade their privacy by searching them just because they want to. Now, if a private company (like private owners of airlines) wants to search people before they allow them to use their property, thats just fine, but they wouldn’t be able to lock you up if you didn’t want to be searched, they could just not allow you to use their property. Try telling the TSA you don’t want to be searched, and then try to leave and see what happens.